AGREKA BOOKS  •  Home  About Us  Book List  Precious Pets Historical Society Books  Art Dept
 

.

John R. Llewellyn has appeared on  Larry King Live, ABC Primetime, The Today Show with Matt Lauer & Katie Couric; NBC Nightly News with Tom Brokaw; Fox News Channel's "The Edge" with Paula Zahn; MSNBC; Inside Edition; Good Morning America, & is contacted frequently by local and foreign press. 

POLYGAMY UNDER ATTACK – FROM TOM GREEN TO  BRIAN DAVID MITCHELL       
   
Choose where to buy online  

   
            
  Amazon US
   ChangingHands.com  BarnesNoble.com   

 Amazon UK   Amazon CA

              

Click cover for larger image.    You may also order this book through your local book store with ISBN number.
  
 By John R. Llewellyn  List Price $15.95
 Agreka™ Books ISBN 1-888106-76-X  Library of Congress 2003117091 
 180 p Soft Cover 6 x 9 with 15 pg photo section  January 2004

The worldwide bombshell of Brian David Mitchell, the itinerant sidewalk preacher who kidnaped Elizabeth Smart, finally brought the world’s attention to what Oprah Winfrey’s show labeled as third-world Taliban-type abuses in Utah and Arizona. The entire world had been focused on publicity hungry Tom Green and his claim of a peaceful life as a polygamist, when Mitchell and his accomplice wife shocked the world by their crime against Elizabeth Smart.

Polygamy expert and retired law enforcement officer John Llewellyn provides a dramatic inside look at each of the polygamist groups, how they began, how they rule their people, their beliefs, and how many are living off your tax dollars. He explores serious human rights abuses that occur in many groups such as forcing young girls to marry men old enough to be their father. A former friend of Tom Green, the author provides deep background on Tom’s life and polygamist activities. John explores the fascinating underground fraud by the various groups and evaluates Brian David Mitchell’s efforts to turn Elizabeth Smart into a compliant plural wife.

And finally, he takes a hard look at the possible value of decriminalizing polygamy so that the many hidden abuses, including tens of millions of dollars of welfare fraud when polygamist wives pose as single mothers with children, can be brought out into the open and finally be dealt with realistically.

  Back Cover Quote: A well documented and well written account of the latter day Mormon Polygamist / Fundamentalist in the Inter-mountain West. It is recommended reading for anyone interested in this subculture.
          Benjamin Bistline, author of
The Polygamists: A History of Colorado City, Arizona

 Click cover for larger image.


 Introduction   About The Author  Table of Contents   Chapter One  

Tom Green Page 2  Excerpts all Chapters Page 3  Polygamy Groups in 2004 

  Photos of Tom Green and Wives  

The Deseret News Brian David Mitchell's Manifesto Focuses on Plural Wives 

  Read John's article on Elizabeth Smart.

Introduction

After sitting through the trial and providing testimony for Juab County prosecutor David Leavitt as he convicted Tom Green of child rape, I began working on this book. As I continued writing, other Polygamy Fundamentalists kept leaping into the headlines with stories of abuse.

Then came the worldwide bombshell of Brian David Mitchell, the itinerant sidewalk preacher who kidnaped Elizabeth Smart. The entire world had been focused on publicity hungry Tom Green and his claim of a peaceful life as a polygamist, when Mitchell and his accomplice wife shocked the world by their crime against Elizabeth Smart.

These highly publicized cases brought the world’s attention to modern-day abuses that many thought only existed in third world countries. The abuses gained so much attention that Oprah Winfrey aired a segment on abusive polygamy in Utah and Arizona, and followed with an interview of Elizabeth and her family in the Smart’s home.

Mounting public concern caused me to realize that people were finally ready to become informed about the practices of each of the Mormon Fundamentalist groups, what they do, and why they say they do it. Organized anti-polygamy groups need public support as they press the government to find realistic solutions.

As a result of all the publicity, Arizona and Utah are taking a hard look at the human rights violations, not to mention the millions of dollars of state and federal welfare money that support the groups when polygamist wives -- claiming to be single mothers with children -- sign up for welfare benefits. One informant reported that her welfare checks are often taken directly to the priesthood leaders of their group.

Concerned citizens need to understand that all these polygamists -- Tom Green, Brian David Mitchell, David Kingston, and others -- have a motivating common denominator from the 1800s. While the mainstream LDS Church abandoned polygamy a century ago, there are thousands of dissidents practicing plural marriage, who call themselves Mormon Fundamentalists.

This book will examine how what is a sacred belief to many people has been criminalized by some of the men within the Fundamentalist Groups. The question every decent citizen must ask: What can be done about it? What will, or can, Utah and the neighboring state of Arizona actually do, if anything? What resources are available. The victims are not just young girls, but women and men too, conditioned from birth to endure abuse under the guise of religious beliefs. They don’t know what to do or where to go.

It is my hope that this book will enlighten society so that the abuses within these groups can be targeted for action, in particular the young girls forced into a plural marriage with men old enough to be their father. In one group, incest is encouraged to "keep a pure blood line."

To make these girls and women become real to unenlightened citizens, I wrote an emotionally-charged and tender fact-based novel A Teenager’s Tears: When Parents Convert to Polygamy. I wanted people to be able to walk in their shoes and feel what they feel, to be on the inside looking out.

It is important to understand that the vast majority of polygamists do not represent a criminal threat to the peace and dignity of American principles. They feel that plural marriage should be decriminalized. And many involved in dealing with the abuses believe that decriminalizing plural marriage would remove the veil of secrecy that allows these abuses to go on, so read the chapter on Decriminalizing Polygamy. With recent Supreme Court decisions, many believe that plural marriage has a good chance to gain legal acceptance.

Those involved in plural marriage who conduct their lives with dignity and respect are as outraged at the abuses as everyone else. This book is intended to help the public and law enforcement better understand what goes on and how it develops. Before solutions can be found, one must first understand the intricate problems involved.

American was founded on religious freedom and individual rights. The government must find a way to preserve these for each citizen, without trampling on the rights we hold so dear.

About The Author

John R. Llewellyn, retired Salt Lake County Sheriff's Lieutenant has been asked to be an advisor to Tapestry Against Polygamy. While in law enforcement, he specialized in sex crime investigation that included polygamy complaints. He compiled an intelligence file on mass murderer Ervil LeBaron, who in 1977 ordered the death of Dr. Rulon C. Allred, leader of Utah's second largest polygamist group. LeBaron, a self-imposed"One Mighty and Strong," attempted to extort tithing from Utah's polygamist groups. John’s book Murder of a Prophet is a paradigm of the Allred murder, and factual expose´ of the dark side of Utah polygamist cults. A Teenager’s Tears: When Parents Convert to Polygamy is a tender, emotionally-charged and moving story that pulls the reader into that world.

In order to best combat and understand the polygamist, deputy Llewellyn studied Mormon doctrine and was converted to Mormonism, and then Mormon Fundamentalism. Impressed with the integrity, virtue and undaunted conviction of many of the polygamists, after his retirement Llewellyn became a member of Apostolic United Brethren. However, when the leadership of Apostolic United Brethren re-postured, claiming "all" the priesthood keys and pretending they were the sole conduit to a celestial exaltation, Llewellyn took a second look at the fundamentalist belief structure and summarily disassociated himself.

Llewellyn, now a muckraker and freelance writer, is recognized as an expert on Mormon Fundamentalism and polygamy. He is also the lead investigator in a lawsuit against polygamist James D. Harmston and his True and Living Church, headquartered at Manti, Utah, as well as a consultant for the Attorney General's Office.

John Llewellyn is uniquely qualified as a polygamy expert and can speak to the issues in a way no one else can. He is highly articulate and thoroughly knowledgeable about law enforcement polygamy strategies, government attitudes, and the vast issues inside and outside of polygamy. He knows all the leaders of polygamy groups, many of their members, and a multitude of polygamists who live outside a group. He is available for interviews by TV and the Press. Contact John: 1 801 259-5415 or call publisher: 1 800 360-5284.

John may be contacted via e-mail: jrllewellyn@apcomp.com.

John R. Llewellyn appeared on the Today Show with Matt Lauer & Katie Couric August 24, 2001; NBC Nightly News with Tom Brokaw, May 21, 2001, on Fox News Channel's "The Edge" with Paula Zahn June 27 2002, on MSNBC March 15, 2003, on Inside Edition March 17, 2003, and on Good Morning America April 4, 2003.

Top

Table of Contents

Chapter One       A Brief History of the Mormon Fundamentalist World

Chapter Two       A Profile of Each Group and the Independents

Chapter Three     Anti-Polygamy & Pro-Polygamy Movements

Chapter Four      An Inside Look at AUB Fraud

Chapter Five       An Inside Look at TLC

Chapter Six        Tom Green and His Wives

Chapter Seven    Bleeding the Beast for Your Tax Dollars

Chapter Eight     Authority versus Love in Mormon Fundamentalism

Chapter Nine      Four Different Attitudes Towards Polygamy

Chapter Ten       Are There Solutions for Polygamy Problems

Chapter Eleven   Rights of Children vs. Rights of Parents

Chapter Twelve   Decriminalizing Plural Marriage

Epilogue             From Tom Green to Brian David Mitchell

The Potential for Violence
Conclusion
End Notes
About the Author
Books About Polygamy

 Top

Chapter One

A Brief History of the Mormon Fundamentalist World

In Utah, Arizona, and neighboring states, even into Canada and Mexico, polygamy practice stems from early Mormon beliefs. Even though not condoned since the late 1800s by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS), thousands of people still practice polygamy today and claim it is the true "Mormonism."

For over a century The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has been known as the Mormon Church, because of their scripture book, the Book of Mormon. But according to current President Gordon B. Hinckley, prophet and leader of the LDS Church, Mormon is a pseudonym that is no longer spiritually acceptable or politically correct. He has asked the media to discontinue referring to the LDS Church as the Mormon Church.

President Hinckley has repeatedly declared that these polygamists are not, and should not be, linked to the LDS Church. When members of the Church are discovered practicing polygamy, they are promptly excommunicated.

But two important facts that complicate the issue should be understood -- the LDS Church still believes in the divinity of plural marriage in heaven, even while it no longer allows members to practice it on earth. And a significant percentage of faithful members of the LDS Church have ancestors who practiced polygamy. Thus, members of the LDS Church today are conflicted over the way some modern-day polygamists should be dealt with.

In Utah and Arizona, members of the LDS Church can be found in government positions, law enforcement, etc., and of course they have mixed feelings about the issue of polygamists. Most people recognize that there are polygamist families who truly believe they are living as God wants them to, thus "religious freedom" comes into play.

What we wish to do in this book is teach and inform our citizenry of the hidden abuses that occur, that such abuses are not found in every family, but where they are found, they must be dealt with. We can no longer turn our heads and pretend it will all go away. It isn’t going away.

Because the polygamists call themselves Mormon Fundamentalists, the word "Mormonisn" is found, heard, and spoken throughout the Fundamentalist world and is necessarily included in this book. There is simply no other word to describe the belief system that underlies plural marriage as found in our part of the world.

The intricate tapestry that makes up the Mormon Fundamentalist subculture can be confusing to a person unfamiliar with Mormonism. There are a number of established groups. Each "group" has its own mode of thought, and each believes it is the jewel of Mormonism, much like Sunnism and Shi’ism, the ‘Abbasids and Ba’th Party are to Islam. Therefore, I will attempt to untangle any confusion and give the reader an idea how each group or individual fits into the whole picture.

Let’s examine the history of the Mormon Fundamentalist movement. The Fundamentalists rejected the LDS Church’s contention that a contemporary revelation or prophet can negate or suspend the revelation of an earlier prophet, in this case, Joseph Smith.

In 1890 Prophet Wilford Woodruff issued a Manifesto prohibiting the further practice of plural marriage which, according to the Church, suspended that portion of the 132nd Section of the D & C that mandated the practice of polygamy. (The LDS Church scriptures are comprised of three standard works: the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Covenants [D&C], and the Pearl of Great Price.) The Fundamentalist position is, if God has not abrogated the practice, and according to the early leaders of the Church, God said he would never abrogate polygamy, then it ought to be lived.

The 1890 Woodruff manifesto ceasing the practice of polygamy is entitled "Official Declaration." The Declaration can be found in the D & C following the 136th Section. Some members of the Church at that time thought the Manifesto was a trick, a pretense that would fool the United States Government and convince them that the LDS Church was committed to ending polygamy, so Utah statehood could follow. But, in fact, it was real.

Mormon Fundamentalism Develops

It wasn’t until after the turn of the century that all members of the Church fully complied with the Manifesto. Then in the 1920s a group of disgruntled Mormons began to hold secret meetings debating the consequences of the LDS Church abandoning "celestial marriage." A fellow named Lorin Woolley showed up at one of the meetings with a fantastic tale, a tale which pro and con historians still endlessly explore.

He claimed that in 1886 while guarding the prophet who was in hiding from federal marshals, LDS Prophet Taylor received a supernatural visitation from Joseph Smith and Jesus Christ. Joseph and the Lord placed President Taylor under covenant to keep alive plural marriage until the Second Coming. The following day, President Taylor held a meeting, which has gone down in Fundamentalist history as "The Eight Hour Meeting."

From that momentous meeting, thousands of former Mormons have justified the continuous practice of polygamy in spite of the LDS Church mandate and laws of the land.

By 1929 the Lorin Woolly story had been refined and edited into plausible fact so that practicing polygamists could honestly say, "I am just living my religion, I’m just carrying out the will of God, it is the only way I can hope to go to the celestial kingdom." (Mormons believe in three heavens, the telestial, terrestrial, and celestial, with celestial being the highest. Within the celestial heaven are three degrees.) Fundamentalists believe that only those who live polygamy will get to the highest degree. They refer to D&C Sections 76 and 131.)

These believers in the alleged 1886 Revelation were still a clandestine group in 1929. And as with any group, a leader must surface. Lorin Woolly became that man. But in "Mormonism" a leader must also have priesthood authority (a bestowal from God), so plausible authority was invented. Non-fundamentalist historians have given the credit of manufacturing priesthood authority to Joseph Musser, who became the leader of the all Mormon Fundamentalists in the 1930s.

The following scenario spiritually contrived by Musser is paraphrased:

The priesthood and church are two separate entities, each have their explicit calling. The Eight Hour Meeting gave the fundamentalists the priesthood and the priesthood is to the church what the husband is to the wife. The church calling is missionary work, spreading the gospel throughout the world; the priesthood calling is to keep alive the practice of plural marriage.

For years the more honorable modern day polygamist leaders like Rulon C. Allred were very supportive of the mainstream LDS Church. But in 1978 that all changed when the LDS Church issued another Official Declaration permitting male members of the Black Race to hold the priesthood.

Fundamentalists were outraged. They perceived the declaration as another example of the LDS Church caving in to political pressure. It was the last straw. First the Church disbanded the "Council of Fifty," the government of God. Then they discontinued the United Order, a form of communalism. Next came plural marriage, the most sacred of all of God’s principles; and finally by giving the priesthood to the Black Race.

The various fundamentalist leaders (each called himself a prophet) over the several polygamist groups were for once in agreement. They predicted that the temples would be polluted and Black men would be taking white women as wives. They believed it was the final and greatest insult to the memory of Joseph Smith and Brigham Young.

But behind that mask of rage, the fundamentalist prophets were delighted. It was the catalyst they had been waiting for, the excuse to supplant the Church, and wrestle away what was left of the LDS Church’s priesthood authority.

The fundamentalist ranks swelled as many disenchanted, conservative Mormons defected over the Black issue. The organized groups, especially Apostolic United Brethren, built their own temples and went into competition with the LDS Church for members and tithing. However, each organized polygamist group leader claimed that the "keys" belonged to him, and according to the D & C, only one man on earth at a time can hold the keys.

Priesthood authority within the Mormon concept is a nebulous concept that has power only when the laity recognizes the authority. It’s not like a stick of dynamite that the prophet carries around coercing the laity to conform or else. The authority is intangible and invisible, but it can be just as deadly as a stick of dynamite under the control of a fundamentalist fanatic like mass murderer Ervil LeBaron. Priesthood authority is a concept without force unless accepted by its followers. Authority is defined in Verse 7 of the 132nd Section of the D & C, and states that only one person on earth at a time can hold the "keys" of the priesthood.

Verse 7 is the single most important passage in the Doctrine & Covenants because in that passage is vested all power. However, there is a problem: the "keys" of authority are indistinct to the senses. The only way they can be detected is by the "spirit," a supernatural manifestation, or by physical and psychological submission to authority.

In order to understand the motives of Mormon Fundamentalists, one must have an understanding of the keys of priesthood authority. Only "one" man, the prophet, seer and revelator, the one holding the keys, has the authority to collect tithing, seal plural marriages for time and all eternity, and give the endowment (a temple ritual). Money, marriage, and temple are the foundation or power of Mormon Fundamentalism. It is in the temple that the endowment is given and the place where celestial marriages are sealed. The priesthood keys gives one man power over the very exaltation of those who submit to his authority. According to Verse 7, the prophet has power over every aspect of the true believer’s life, that is of course, if the prophet can convince the true believer he alone holds the coveted keys.

At the present time there are dozens of men who portend to be the one holding the keys. Gordon B. Hinckley, president of the LDS Church, tops the list because he is the most powerful, but that doesn’t discourage ambitious fundamentalist usurpers from scrambling to attract a following and collect their share of the glory and tithing.

It is estimated that there are between 25 and 100 thousand polygamists in and around Utah. In the author’s opinion there are no more than 30 thousand and that’s pushing it. Some pundits deliberately inflate the numbers to make it appear the polygamists are more powerful, or the problem is worse than it really is.

In the early days Joseph Musser, living in Salt Lake City, was the recognized fundamentalist leader of all the people practicing polygamy, no matter where they actually lived. They referred to themselves as "living the principle."

In about 1926 Leroy Johnson (also called Roy and Uncle Roy) helped pioneer a settlement in a remote, inhospitable Arizona desert called Short Creek. The town was renamed Colorado City in 1961. Their population expanded west across the Utah border and formed Hildale, Utah. It looks like one community from the air.

In the early days there came a time when disagreements developed among the people and a split occurred. The debate as who was right continues to this day. Nevertheless, nearly all of the organized polygamist groups evolved either directly or indirectly from that split. A detailed explanation of all that unfolded from the very beginning is contained in The Polygamists: A History of Colorado City, Arizona by historian Ben Bistline, who lived through it all. Today there are a number of groups.

The central theme of all the organized Mormon Fundamentalist groups is plural marriage, or more correctly, polygyny, and is the axis around which the fundamentalist world revolves. It is powerful dogma. If you believe that Joseph Smith was a prophet, then you must believe that plural marriage is God’s word to the Mormons. It is said that Joseph Smith was an illiterate farm boy who couldn’t have invented the Book of Mormon, but in reading the writings of Joseph, unless it has been carefully edited, it is not the writings of an uneducated, inarticulate boy. Mormonism is sophisticated doctrine.

Read more in the book. . .

 Top

Manifesto Focuses on Plural Wives

By Jennifer Dobner
Deseret News staff writer
March 15, 2003

The rambling prophecies of Brian David Mitchell in a 27-page written manifesto call upon his wife, Wanda Barzee, to take as many as 49 sister-wives – an act that would reward the two with countless blessings.

"And thou shalt take into thy heart and home seven times, seven sisters to love and care for; forty-nine precious jewels in thy crown, and thou art the jubilee of them all, first and last," wrote the accused captor of 15-year-old Elizabeth Smart. . . .

The writings follow a pattern typical of fundamentalist religious sects, particularly those founded by former members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, said John R. Llewellyn, a retired Salt Lake County sheriff's deputy and a well-known expert on Utah's polygamous communities.

"It's his own special brand of Mormon fundamentalism," said Llewellyn, who has written four books on the topic and is working on a fifth about polygamist Tom Green, who was convicted of bigamy in 2000. "I had no idea he was that deeply involved in fundamentalism because of his Islamic dress. I guess he's improvised to give an Islamic blend to it all."

Mitchell, his wife and Elizabeth were seen around Salt Lake City wearing long robes. The women also wore scarves and veiled their faces.

Many of Mitchell's writings echo the words and ideas of other fundamentalists, Llewellyn said. "Fundamentalists are great copiers. And everything evolves around plural marriage and the women. As you read this, that's the central focus," said Llewellyn, who for a time was himself a member of the Apostolic United Brethren, a Wasatch Front polygamous group. "It's basically how fundamentalists justify their lifestyle."

. . . . Llewellyn said Mitchell "wants to be a modern prophet. To carry on what Joseph Smith and Brigham Young did. (Fundamentalists) all want to feel like they have holy blood. They all form some kind of delusion along those lines to give them special authority.". . . . jdobner@desnews.com

Books on polygamy. Click to read more.
1) A Teenager's Tears: When Parents Convert to Polygamy  
2)
Murder of a Prophet: Dark Side of Utah Polygamy

3) Polygamy Under Attack: From Tom Green to Brian David Mitchell
4) The Polygamists: A History of Colorado City, Arizona 
5) Colorado City, Arizona: An Outsider's Look at the Polygamists

6) Polygamy's Rape of Rachael Strong: Protected Environment for Predators

 Top

  © Agreka Books • Contact  • Customer Service  • Privacy Site Map  Order